Walleye Vs Pike – Which Fish Is Better?

Whether you’re a fishing enthusiast or just curious about these fascinating species, this comparison of Walleye vs. pike will help you understand why both Walleye and Pike are highly sought-after catches. So, let’s explore what makes Walleye and Pike stand out in freshwater fishing.

Regarding freshwater fishing, few species capture the hearts and attention of anglers like Walleye and Pike. These impressive predators inhabit the lakes and rivers, presenting unique challenges and excitement to those who pursue them.

Walleye Vs Pike

In this Comparison, we will take a closer look at Walleye and Pike, exploring what makes each of them unique in terms of their characteristics, where they live, and why they’re so exciting to fish for.

Check Walleye Vs Bass.


Difference between Walleye and Pike: Walleye Vs Pike

Difference between Walleye and Pike Walleye Vs Pike

Species

  • Walleye, scientifically known as Sander vitreus, is a freshwater fish native to North America. They are commonly found in lakes and rivers throughout the United States and Canada.
  • Northern Pike, known as Esox lucius, often referred to simply as “pike,” is a widespread freshwater fish species found in North America, Europe, and parts of Asia. 

Check How To Catch Walleye?

Appearance

  • Walleye have an olive or brownish-green colouring on their back, gradually fading to a white or pale yellowish colour on their belly. They are known for their large, glassy eyes with a milky, reflective layer at the back of the eye that enhances their vision in low-light conditions, such as during dawn and dusk. The distinctive cloudy appearance in their eyes is one of their most notable features and the reason for their name “walleye.”
  • Northern Pike has a long, slender body with a greenish or yellowish colouration. They often have dark vertical bars or spots along their sides, which can vary in intensity depending on their age and environment. Their snout is elongated and duckbill-like, housing a mouth full of sharp teeth, a feature that makes them efficient predators.

Size

  • Walleye typically range in size from 12 to 30 inches in length and can weigh between 1 to 15 pounds. These are the common size ranges for most Walleye. However, it’s important to note that they can grow larger, with some individuals reaching lengths of 40 inches or more. These larger Walleye are considered trophy catches and are highly sought after by anglers.
  • Northern Pike are indeed known for their larger size compared to Walleye. They commonly grow to 20 to 40 inches long, and Pike in this size range are frequently encountered. Some individuals can reach lengths exceeding 50 inches and weigh over 30 pounds, especially in optimal conditions. These larger northern Pike are considered trophy fish and are prized catches among anglers who target them.

Fins

  • Walleye and Pike have different fins, which can help anglers to distinguish between the two species. The main difference between walleye and pike fins is the number of dorsal fins. Walleye has two dorsal fins, while Pike has one dorsal fin. Additionally, the dorsal fin on Walleye is spiny, while the dorsal fin on Pike is soft.

The following table summarizes the key differences between walleye and Pike fins:

FeatureWalleye Pike
Dorsal FinsTwoOne
Pectoral FinsTwoTwo
Pelvic FinsTwoTwo
Anal FinOneOne
Caudal finOneOne
Spines in dorsal finYesNo
Location of dorsal finNear the middle of the backTowards the back of the fish

Habitat and Feeding Habits

  • Walleye prefers clean and cool freshwater environments, such as lakes and rivers. They are often found in deeper waters, particularly during the day, and are commonly associated with structures like rocks, drop-offs, and underwater vegetation. Walleye are known for their nocturnal feeding habits, and they tend to move to shallower waters and become more active during low-light conditions, such as dawn and dusk.
  • Northern pikes are indeed more versatile in terms of habitat and can thrive in various freshwater environments. In some cases, they are often found in lakes, rivers, ponds, and even brackish waters. Northern Pike prefers areas with ample cover, such as weed beds, submerged logs, and aquatic vegetation, where they can conceal themselves and ambush their prey. These Fish are known for their preference for areas with abundant prey species and are often found in regions with a healthy fish population.

Diet

  • Walleye are primarily known for their nocturnal feeding habits, which means they are most active during low-light conditions, such as dawn and dusk. Their diet primarily consists of Fish, including minnows, perch, and other small aquatic creatures. Walleye are skilled ambush predators and use their excellent low-light vision to surprise and capture their prey.
  • Northern Pikes are indeed aggressive predators with a wide-ranging diet. They are known for their voracious appetite and will prey on various animals, including Fish, frogs, small mammals, and even birds. Their sharp teeth and powerful jaws allow them to strike at prey with precision and force, making them effective hunters in aquatic ecosystems.

Fishing

  • Walleye anglers often use a variety of bait and lure to catch Walleye. Live bait, such as minnows or nightcrawlers, can be very effective, especially when fishing near the bottom or in deeper waters. Artificial lures designed for Walleye, such as jigs, crankbaits, and soft plastics, are popular among anglers. Walleye are known to be active during winter, making them popular targets for ice fishing. Ice anglers use specialized equipment, such as tip-ups and ice jigs, to catch Walleye beneath the frozen surface.
  • Pike are commonly caught using various techniques, and they are well-known for their aggressive strikes and fighting ability. Large artificial lures, such as spoons, spinnerbaits, and swimbaits, are frequently used to target Pike. These lures mimic the size and movement of their natural prey. Live baitfish, such as suckers or chubs, can also be effective, especially when fished beneath a float or on a set line. Some anglers even enjoy fly fishing for northern Pike, using large streamers and other fly patterns that imitate Fish or other prey.

Walleye and Pike

Walleye

The Walleye is a beloved fish for a multitude of reasons. 

Walleye
  • Its mild, sweet flavour and tender, flaky texture make it versatile for various cooking methods, from frying and grilling to baking and poaching. 
  • Anglers are drawn to Walleye for their impressive fighting ability, as these Fish put up a strong resistance when hooked, providing an exciting challenge. 
  • Moreover, Walleye’s widespread distribution across North America and relative abundance in many regions make it an accessible and popular choice for anglers of all skill levels. 
  • Beyond the fishing community, Walleye holds economic significance, serving as a valuable commercial fish and a driving force behind the tourism industry.
  • Furthermore, Walleye’s popularity is deeply rooted in culture; for instance, it holds the distinction of being the state fish in Minnesota and Ohio. 
  • Beyond these factors, there are more compelling reasons for its appeal. 
  • Walleye is a healthy option as it is low in mercury and other contaminants while offering a good source of protein and beneficial omega-3 fatty acids. 
  • Its sustainability is another virtue, with well-managed populations in most areas ensuring they are not overfished. 

Check How To Jig For Walleye?

Whether you’re an angler seeking an exciting catch, a health-conscious consumer, or a fan of sustainable dining, Walleye’s delectable taste, thrilling pursuit, and eco-friendly attributes make it a popular choice cherished by fishing enthusiasts and food connoisseurs alike.

Pike

Pike are a highly favoured fish species, and their popularity is attributed to several key factors. 

Pike
  • First and foremost, anglers appreciate Pike for their formidable fighting ability and aggressive nature, making them a thrilling challenge to catch. 
  • Additionally, Pike can achieve impressive sizes, with some individuals weighing over 50 pounds, making them a sought-after trophy fish. Their versatility in fishing methods, including trolling, casting, and live bait fishing, makes them accessible to anglers of varying skill levels. 
  • Widely distributed across North America and Europe, Pike’s availability adds to their appeal, both for recreational fishing and their economic importance in the commercial and tourism sectors.
  • Furthermore, Pike are esteemed for their distinctive appearance and predatory behaviour, often occupying the role of apex predators in their ecosystems and helping control other fish populations. 
  • Beyond these attributes, Pike offers health-conscious consumers a relatively healthy option, being low in contaminants like mercury while providing protein and omega-3 fatty acids. 
  • They are recognized for their sustainability, as well-managed populations in most regions ensure they are not at risk of overfishing.
  • Lastly, their white, flaky meat with a mild flavour makes them a delectable culinary choice, suitable for various cooking methods.

Overall, Pike’s reputation as a challenging, versatile, sustainable, and delicious fish makes them a beloved species enjoyed by both anglers and culinary enthusiasts.


Similarities between Walleye and Pike

Overall, Walleye and Pike are two very different Fish, but they also share some important similarities. 

Similarities between Walleye and Pike
  • Both Walleye and northern Pike belong to the same family of Fish, known as the Esox family. This family connection indicates that they are closely related in terms of their evolutionary history and genetic makeup.
  • Walleye and pike share similar physical characteristics. They have long, slender bodies with forked tails, which contribute to their streamlined shapes. Additionally, they both have large mouths filled with sharp teeth, which are adapted for capturing and consuming other Fish.
  • Both Walleye and Pike are considered piscivores, which means their primary diet consists of other Fish. They are skilled hunters in freshwater ecosystems and prey on various species of Fish.
  • Walleye and Pike are versatile in terms of habitat. They can be found in various freshwater environments, including lakes, rivers, and reservoirs. 
  • Both Walleye and Pike are highly valued as game fish
  • Both species hold the position of apex predators within their respective ecosystems.

Check Is walleye A Good Fish To Eat?


Why is Raw Walleye better than Raw Pike? Nutritional Comparison Walleye vs. Northern Pike

Nutritional Comparison per 100gWalleyePike
1.77x more lipids per 100g1.22 g0.69 g
2.36x more iron per 100g1.3 mg0.55 mg
12mg more sodium per 100g51 mg39 mg
3.49x more copper per 100g178 mg51 mg
3.33x more manganese per 100g800 mg240 mg
5.68% more food energy (kcal) per 100g93 kcal88 kcal
5.71% more food energy (kJ) per 100g389 kJ368 kJ
1.87x more monounsaturated fatty acids per 100g294 g 157 g

Source : versus.com


My Final Thoughts: Which Fish is Better? 

Walleye are often considered to be superior table fares due to their mild, delicate flavour and firm texture. They are a popular choice among anglers who enjoy not only the thrill of the catch but also the satisfaction of a delicious meal.

While Northern Pike may not be as renowned for their taste as Walleye, they still provide a pleasant dining experience. Pike are prized for their fighting ability and offer an exciting challenge to anglers.

Ultimately, the choice between Walleye and northern Pike depends on an angler’s priorities. Some may prefer the culinary aspect and opt for Walleye, while others may be drawn to the excitement of catching northern Pike. Regardless of the choice, both fish species contribute to the diversity and richness of freshwater fishing experiences.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.